In 2004, Rodale filed suit against Men's Fitness for its redesign, "a copycat version-one that is obviously intended to confuse consumers." In May 2006, the magazine published a limited edition color cover of Josh Holloway. In 2004, Men's Health began putting celebrities and athletes on the cover, and with their shirts on-a departure from the covers of the 1990s. The director for print strategy at a media firm said the mention was "too small of a plug to get brands excited." A spokesperson for the American Society of Magazine Editors said that no rules were broken. Zinczenko said the lines saved readers from having to dig for information and that Men's Health had been including the lines for over a year regardless of advertiser status. We plan to keep using the most effective marketing tools to reach the largest market we possibly can." In July 2010, the magazine was criticized for including tiny credit lines on the cover rather than inside as a possible quid-pro-quo for advertisers. "Twenty years of Men's Health has certainly produced several lines that have proven themselves effective at newsstand, which makes up about 20 percent of our print run. Zinczenko replied that 80 percent of magazine sales are by subscription, and those covers differ from the newsstand version. Men's Health has been criticized for reusing cover taglines. We turned health into a concept every guy would want to embrace, starting with the healthy guy on the cover." The New York Times stated, "Since its debut in the late 1980s, the magazine has surpassed traditional men's books like Esquire and GQ by following the formula of best-selling women's magazines-by catering to men's anxieties about their bodies and sexual performance." Columbia Journalism Review stated the magazine "deals overwhelmingly with self-care and, in fact, exaggerates the possibilities for autonomous personal transformation." Editor-In-Chief Zinczenko argued that the magazine worked toward "overcoming the resistance of the 86-percent male audience to health as a subject" and redefining health as "inclusive of everything that could improve a man's life. Men's Health magazine has been criticized for its focus on physical health, which can increase men's anxieties about their bodies, making them more prone to eating disorders and compulsive over-exercising. In 2006, the circulation was close to 1.8 million. In 2001, the magazine started the annual list of cities with the healthiest men, based on twenty "live-long parameters, including death rates (both homicide and disease) illness rates (high blood pressure, heart disease, stroke, etc.) body-mass index fitness training even environmental factors like number of parks, golf courses, etc." In 2003, the circulation was 1.7 million. In 2001 the title was consistently selling 400,000 copies at newsstands and circulation was 1.6 million. In 2000, the brand had 21 international editions. Circulation increased 30 percent, ad pages by 80 percent from 700 to 1150. Zinczenko became editor-in-chief in 2000. After one year, Gutfeld was replaced by David Zinczenko. Lafavore left Men's Health in 2000, the same year Capell's Circulation Report named the magazine Circulation Performer of the Decade. He worked with longtime staff editor Denis Boyles, a former Playboy contributing editor, to develop the magazine's voice. He created the editorial formula, hired Steven Slon from service journalism and Greg Gutfeld from Prevention. The South African version, along with Women's Health, is licensed for publication by Media24, with distribution by Magzter. In his 12 years as editor-in-chief, Lafavore increased the circulation from 100,000 to over 1.5 million, increased publication to ten 10 times a year and expanded the magazine to Australia, France, Germany, Mexico, Russia, South Africa and the UK. Bricklin, who was editor-in-chief of Prevention magazine, appointed Mike Lafavore as editor of Men's Health that year. The results led Rodale to start Men's Health as a quarterly magazine in 1988 and begin to sell subscriptions. Bricklin, Rodale editors Larry Stains and Stefan Bechtel produced three newsstand test issues. Started by Mark Bricklin in the US in 1986 as a health magazine, Men's Health evolved into a lifestyle magazine, covering fitness, nutrition, relationships, travel, technology, fashion and finance. Men’s Health is published in numerous countries and has employed well known journalists, such as Evgeny Kogan in the Russian edition. The magazine's website,, averages over 118 million page views a month. Although originally started as a men's health magazine, it currently covers various men's lifestyle topics such as fitness, nutrition, fashion and sexuality. It is also the best-selling men's magazine on US newsstands. Men's Health ( MH), published by Hearst, is the world's largest men's magazine brand, with 35 editions in 59 countries.